Discussion about this post

User's avatar
James Emanuel's avatar

This is a truly excellent post and it addresses something I myself have pondered many times.

In my book, 'Fabric of Success', I discuss how Anthony Deden shares a poignant anecdote about an Arab date farmer who, with great satisfaction, planted saplings that would take 40 years to produce commercial-quality fruit, almost certainly not within his lifetime. The dates being harvested today were planted by previous generations, for which the farmer is grateful. His work in planting trees for the benefit of his children and grandchildren is selfless, involving significant short-term opportunity costs, but he understands that his task is to protect, preserve, and enhance what he was given to manage. It isn’t about him or a desire for personal enrichment. To coin a Steve Jobs expression, it’s about being a missionary rather than a mercenary. The durability and future value of the business is all that matters. If everyone who inherited control of the date farm followed his example, the farm would forever prosper. If not, it would eventually fail.

Deden suggests that many corporate leaders today are overly focused on the short term. With the average tenure of a public company CEO being around four years, there is little incentive for them to make decisions that will benefit the company and its shareholders for decades to come. Instead, they often concentrate on poorly designed short-term remuneration targets which encourage the wrong type of thinking. This explains why Deden avoids investing in the vast majority of public companies. Instead he advocates investing in businesses with long-term leadership, typically founders or families, with a demonstrable bias towards achieving enduring success across multiple generations.

This all speaks to the mindset of the management and the corporate culture. There is a wonderful freight company in New Zealand which is worthy of study for anyone who is unfamiliar with it. It's called Mainfreight and it was established by Bruce Plestead. In 1979 he established a corporate constitution which he named 'The Mainfreight Way'. At its core, it had a 100-year vision which influences all recruitment, staff training, customer and supplier relationships, growth strategies and capital allocation. Essentially, every decision is made by considering what is best for the company to endure for the next 100 years. The book about Mainfreight is titled "Ready Fire Aim: The Mainfreight Story" by Keith Davies, published in 2013. Highly recommended.

To adopt this kind of mindset, management need to be long tenured. Both Deden's date farmer and Plestead were in it for the long-term. But consider that the average tenure of a CEO for a US public company is only 4.2 years, and you can see why this is a problem. Every time management changes, shareholders are essentially rolling the dice on their investment. And with each roll, there’s always the risk of a bad outcome. The question is - how many times are you willing to take that gamble? I am publishing a great video on this topic tomorrow on my Substack entitled, "Rolling the Dice: The Leadership Gamble" if anyone is interested. In this analysis on Phil Carret, I also explore the importance of great long-term management: https://rockandturner.substack.com/p/phil-carret-learn-from-the-best?utm_source=publication-search

Warren Buffett was influenced by Phil Fischer in adopting the "favourite holding period is forever". The philosophy here is that interrupting compounding is more costly than most think. I explore this, with supporting facts and figures here: https://rockandturner.substack.com/p/investing-subconscious-myopia . However, with CEOs of most companies changing so frequently, and the potential impact of a new leader being profound, this is not so easy to achieve.

This is why investing in founder led businesses, that nurture talent and promote from within, and which have strong succession plans, is key to this conundrum. These are the kinds of businesses I look for. Examples include Costco, Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway, Mainfreight, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Fastenal. All of these companies share a corporate philosophy that works. This was the focus of my book, which pulls on the golden threads that run through the fabric of every great business. If you are interested, you can find it on Amazon here: https://www.amazon.com/Fabric-Success-Threads-Tapestry-Business-ebook/dp/B0D6GWV7T5

Expand full comment
Sanjay's avatar

Svenska Handelsbanken AB is quite an interesting study

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts